‘Inherit the Wind’ revives fundamental conflicts

 

Prosecutors Tom Davenport (Christopher Kale Jones, left) and Matthew Harrison Brady (Alexander Gemignani) confer with defense attorney Henry Drummond (Harry Lennix) as a potential juror (Terry Bell) looks on in "Inherit the Wind" at Goodman Theatre.

Christopher Kale Jones, Alexander Gemignani, Harry Lennix and Terry Bell in “Inherit the Wind” at Goodman Theatre. (Photo by Liz Lauren)

Recommended

The Goodman Theatre reminds us that the more things change the more they remain the same in this production of “Inherit the Wind,” a classic courtroom drama directed by Henry Godinez.

The 1955 play by Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee was written as a vehicle to shed light on the anti-communist proceedings of the McCarthy era. But, the story resonates with us again in 2024 as many of the same and several new public conflicts are debated between those holding opposing political ideologies as well as fundamentalist religious beliefs versus scientific discovery. (Think book-banning in some libraries and schools>)

Small town schoolteacher Bertram Cates (Christopher Llewyn Ramirez) is on trial for breaking a state law that prohibits the teaching of evolution.

The prosecution is aided by the bombastic self-important fundamentalist, bible thumping Matthew Harrison Brady (Alexander Gemignani).  Cates is represented by famed Chicago lawyer Henry Drummond (Harry Lennix), a publicly demonized, clever defense attorney known for taking on difficult and controversial cases.

The premise is a fictionalized version of the infamous 1925 Scopes Monkey Trial where three-time presidential candidate and former secretary of state William Jennings Bryan argued for the prosecution and Clarence Darrow served as defense attorney for science teacher John T. Scopes.

The authors do not suggest that religion and science are irreconcilable but rather that this chasm has occurred because one group strives to stand still, hanging on to the status quo, while the other strives to advance human knowledge with a willingness to see where it leads.

For over a half century this play has been produced by hundreds (maybe thousands) of production companies of every size and skill level, including one movie and three television versions. Drummond and Brady are epic characters every serious actor would be happy to have a chance to play. It is a clash of titans utilizing witty, thought provoking, well written dialogue as their chosen weapons.

In this production Harry Lennix as Drummond wears the part well, articulating every word with clarity as though they have sprung extemporaneously from his own mind. It is the kind of performance we have come to expect of a Goodman production.

Alexander Gemignani as the dogmatic Brady is a worthy adversary for Lennix. When the two are on stage together you can feel the charge of energy flowing between them.

Ryan Kitley provides a stirring performance as hellfire and damnation preacher Reverend Jeremiah Brown.

Alexander Gemignani and Harry Lennix (Photo by Liz Lauren)

The use of the young boy, Howard (Thomas Murphy Molony), as a witness to proceedings was not something I remember in previous productions. Yes, he is literally a witness for the prosecution but he is also present virtually throughout the play witnessing the interactions of the principal players both in and out of the courtroom. He represents the future and it is his responsibility to bring forth the “truth,” whatever it may be, to the next generation.

There are a few actors on stage who provided acceptable performances but might take this opportunity to tune into Mr. Lennix masterclass on dialogue. Getting the lines out is admirable, and luckily, Lawrence and Lee provide lines that are difficult to mess up, But taking it to the next level requires understanding exactly what you are saying so that the words sound like they are your own and the audience understands the nuance behind them. No doubt this will improve over the run of the play.

The interesting set design by Collette Pollard features a suspended circular diorama lowers the ceiling. It contributes to the sense that the action is taking place within a confined space but also within the context of a small town someplace in the universe.

A beautiful parquet floor similarly grounds the actors providing a sense of place that keeps the action in the center of a rather large stage. The furnishings are sparse allowing us to stay focused on the actors. 

Back in 1925 the trial was about Darwin’s theory of evolution versus religious fundamentalism. And now, in 2024, almost 100 years later, we are again hearing from similarly opposed factions as they, once more, argue what should and should not be covered in schools.

DETAILS: “Inherit the Wind” is at the Goodman Theatre, 170 N Dearborn Street, Chicago, IL through October 20, 2024. Runtime is around 2 hours and 15 minutes, including a 15-minute intermission. For tickets and more information visit www.goodmantheatre.org

 Reno Lovison

For more shows visit Theatre in Chicago

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *