Recommended
Have you ever walked through a gallery, studied a face in a painting and wondered who that person is and what is their backstory?
In “Sunday in the Park with George” originally produced in 1982, playwright James Lapine partnered with composer/lyricist Stephen Sondheim to lift the otherwise anonymous images from Georges Seurat’s famed work A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte and give them life. This thoughtful conceit takes the opportunity to use these characters to delve into the thought processes of the artist, and earned Lapine a Pulitzer Prize for Drama.
For those unfamiliar with the painting, it can be seen in person at The Art Institute of Chicago. Seurat’s massive nearly 10-foot-wide masterpiece depicts a collection of figures of various social classes strolling and lounging along the Seine River in a park just outside Paris circa 1885. The artist utilizes a technique he developed called pointillism where small dots of pure color are placed very close together requiring the viewer’s eyes to blend them into a wider variety of tones. This was a revolution that ultimately led to the development of the modern four-color printing process.
Seurat’s genius as an avant garde artist and visionary is the basis of this production at the Chopin Downstairs Studio produced by Kokandy Productions under the direction of Derek Van Barham with musical director Nick Sula.
It seems Sondheim took inspiration from Seurat as an opportunity to experiment with his own musical colors and tones. The music here is much more freestyle and amorphous then his previous works. You can hear that the composer is working to blend musical tones and find unusual harmonies combining with his own distinctive use of complex rhythms in an effort to create new sounds — often pleasant, at times assaulting, but always thought provoking. This work has little reference to the works of his mentor Oscar Hammerstein or to our recently reviewed “West Side Story” in which he collaborated with Leonard Bernstein. You’ll be hard pressed to walk out of the theater humming a tune or recalling a musical phrase. But that’s not altogether a bad thing. Sondheim is asking us to think differently to experience his music in a way that is similar to how Seurat’s new approach to visual art was received.
The story is told almost entirely through the interactions between the artist Georges Seurat (Kevin Webb) and his muse Dot (Missy Wise Vanderzee). The massive role keeps Webb on stage nearly the entire time. When not with Dot he is conferring with fellow artist Jules (Danny Andrew Bennett), the Boatman (Nick Arceo) or his mother (Lauren Miller) with whom he has a lovely duet toward the end of Act I.
As always, the entire Kokandy cast offer outstanding vocal performances, particularly evident in the title choral number Sunday in the Park with George. Webb who has also tackled Sondheim in “Sweeny Todd” and “Into the Woods” does a terrific job here with very challenging dialogue and rhythm. The cast is accompanied by the exceptionally capable six-piece Kokandy orchestra, who rise to the complexities of Sondheim’s sophisticated score with confident musicality.
Nathe Robotham as Jules’ particularly tall partner Yvonne is inspired by the central figure in the painting who seems unusually out of proportion. Robotham’s catty performance is amusing and their imposing frame is perfect. Ella Carson as Yvonne and Jules’ daughter is delightful while Arceo makes the most of his role as the gruff boatman.
Act I is a very straightforward dive into the mind of Seurat. Act II takes an unexpected turn, advancing the story about 150 years forward where we encounter another George who may or may not be the great grandchild of the artist. This George is also an avant garde artist experimenting with technology. Through George II, Lapine and Sondheim have a chance to consider the notion of legacy in Children and Art. It is questionable whether George II is actually related to George I but there is an inference that the efforts of George Seurat broadened the idea of what art can be, paving the way for future experimental artists. In this way George II is the inheritor of his legacy.
Lapine and Sondheim also offer a sardonic commentary on the business of making art particularly in the musical number Putting It Together.
There is an attempt at the beginning of the second act to offer a transition in the amusing number It’s Hot Up Here, where the historic characters grouse about being stuck in the painting for eternity.
All in all, Act II is something of a mess that includes a slide show that attempts to educate the audience about Seurat as a prelude to George II’s work. It all seems a bit ill conceived and forced as though there was a feeling the show needed to be longer or needed more of a message. It’s not unenjoyable but just requires you to shift gears for a postlude that apparently has no basis in fact since Seurat and Dot seem to have had two children both of whom died in infancy. But this is theater, not an art history class.
Costumes by Rachel Sypniewski were adequate in Act I but quite inspired in Act II, again poking fun at the perceived flamboyant antics of the modern art world.
I think I understand why Van Barham might have chosen to stage this in the Chopin’s downstairs studio theater in an attempt to create an immersive experience that would bring the audience into the painting and into Seurat’s world but this play begs for a proscenium. It is about the perceived confines of what art is and what it can be. It is about a particular painting in a frame that has very specific proportions and use of space. It is also about perception of outdoor light. It is expansive and needs more air than this venue can provide. Likewise, the lighting by G. “Max” Maxin was limited by the space. From where I was sitting most of the lighting seemed to be directed toward me and often annoyingly in my eyes. The unveiling of the painting was a dramatic surprise but it could not be seen by everyone at the same time so missed a dramatic beat.
Ultimately Lapine and Sondheim’s opus is a theatrical tour deforce with perhaps a few hiccups that is a favorite among sophisticated theater goers who are open to experiencing a challenging score — in this case performed terrifically with great vocals and instrumentation. If you love Sondheim, you’ll love this.
DETAILS: “Sunday in the Park with George” presented by Kokandy Productions is at Chopin Downstairs Studio, 1543 W. Division Street, Chicago, IL through November 1, 2026. Runtime is 2.5 hours with one 15-minute intermission. For tickets and information visit kokandyproductions.com
Review by Reno Lovison
For more shows visit Theatre in Chicago








