
Highly Recommended
Repression, Power, and Renewal
A Quaker couple living in Dublin, Ireland circa 1850, invite a former enslaved African-American woman and her companion to spend ten weeks in their home while touring the British Isle promoting the abolitionist movement. Their visit concludes on the spring equinox bringing a promise of rebirth and new beginnings.
The Sugar Wife is a story of devotion in all of its manifestations including faith, love, and charity — as well as devotion to work and artistic expression. The pivotal titular character is Hannah (Annie Hogan) whose husband Samuel Tewkley (Todd Wojcik) is a sugar and tea merchant.
On the surface the couple are devoted to their religion and to each other living a comparatively comfortable affluent life while maintaining a superficially austere façade consistent with Quaker ideals.
Hannah endeavors to offset their privilege through myriad good deeds and charity work represented here primarily though her visitations to Martha Ryan (Kristin Collins) a syphilitic sex worker who is literally on her deathbed.
Having visitors for nearly three months brings a level of intimacy that causes each person to reveal much of their inner character, exposing painful desires, repressed passions and secret motivations.
Sarah Worth (Ashayla Calvin) the formerly enslaved woman is accompanied by Alfred Darby (John LaFlamboy) a privileged white man who bought her freedom. Darby an amateur photographer, engaged in the nascent art form, acts as her manager, arranging her speaking opportunities, though it is apparent their relationship is more complicated than it appears on the surface.
Integrity is the alignment between what you believe, what you say, and what you do and is a key element with each character. Keeping this balance is a constant human struggle. Many people make bargains with themselves to justify actions that are in conflict with their ideals, some repent and other simply surrender to their baser instincts.
Weaving throughout the story is a theme of sexual power represented by a slave, a prostitute, and a woman in an unhappy marriage. But this theme is not simply one of domination but rather one of symbiosis as the players leverage their power to maintain their own survival and meet their own objectives.
In the end, with the coming of spring, the question becomes whether they can each emerge from their cold dark wintry past and find a new way forward.
The U.S. Premiere of The Sugar Wife written by Elizabeth Kuti and presented by Artistic Home is expertly directed by Kevin Hagan in the round providing a particularly intimate experience.
The exceptional cast is headed tenderly by Annie Hogan. In spite of his character’s personal failings Todd Wojcik portrays Samuel with a sympathetic and oddly endearing quality that adds pathos to his inner conflicts.
I wish Ashayla Calvin as Sarah Worth had been given more to do. Her understandable detachment from the others makes her feel present mainly to motivate them – – though her oratory vignettes were powerfully delivered giving her notable talent a few welcome opportunities to shine.
John LaFlamboy portrayed Sarah’s companion Alfred Darby with an undercurrent of danger that keeps you wondering about him while Kristin Collins as the bedridden Martha injected a bit of dark comic relief delivering a defiant air that suggested she was not giving up the ghost easily.
This is a provocative and intellectually engaging examination of integrity and interpersonal relationships within the context of rigid social constraints and gender expectations of the 19th century.
Details: The Sugar Wife is at Theater Wit, 1229 W Belmont, Chicago IL through May 3, 2026. Runtime is about 2 ½ hours with one intermission. For information visit theaterwit.org or call 773-975-8150.
Review by Reno Lovison
For more reviews visit Theatre in Chicago







Madelyn Loehr (Candice), Monique Marshaun (Sandra) and Makari Tobinson-McNeese (Malik) Photo by A.R. Boseman