Highly Recommended
Fiddler on the Roof at Music Theater Works touches the very essence of our need to belong, the stigma of otherness and our fear of expulsion.
The action takes place at the turn of the twentieth century in the fictional shtetl of Anatevka in Eastern Europe’s Pale of Settlement somewhere near Kyiv.
At the beginning of the play Tevye, a Jewish dairyman with five daughters, expertly portrayed by Sam Nachison, explains the importance of balance as exemplified by the metaphor of a fiddler on the roof.
He acknowledges the reality of what it means to be part of a group that is quite separate but existing within a larger culture. A certain balance of conformity must be maintained in order to enjoy some level of non-conformity. But as we learn, this balance is maintained largely at the pleasure of those with the greatest power.
Tevye taps into our most personal sense of identity. The story asks us to consider what defines our community? Is it a connection to place, a connection to people or is it our connection to rituals?
The answer is clear “A little bit of this, a little bit of that…” does not make a life. People come and go, but rituals can be maintained under any circumstances. TRADITION!
This occurs at the dawn of the modern era requiring a need to accept change and to adapt.
Some like Fyedka, a young local non-Jew (Jake Mickel), and Tevye’s third daughter Chava (Madison Jaffe-Richter), attempt to assimilate.
Many urban intellectuals like Perchik (Jacob Simon) and second daughter Hodel (Elissa Newcorn) are drawn to social change in an attempt to equalize the injustices of what had been a largely monarchical system throughout Europe. It is one that favored the rich and their supporters who actively excluded those they felt were inferior, often defined by race, religion or some other outsider affiliation.
Eldest daughter, Tzeitel (Madison Uphoff), and Motel (Nathan Kabara), the tailor embrace technology as is evidenced by his purchase of a sewing machine. But the couple represents those attempting to maintain the status quo by staying close to their cultural roots and trying to keep their current community together at least on the family level.
Celebrating its 60th anniversary this year, Fiddler on the Roof is a very enjoyable, humorous and at times melancholy musical play written by Joseph Stein based on a collection of stories by Sholem Aleichem. Music and lyrics are by Jerry Bock and Sheldon Harnick.
This version, directed by L. Walter Stearns, is as good as any I have seen (and I have seen several).

The scenic design of Bob Knuth was simple and fresh. It basically creates a jumbled collection of bare wood slats framing the proscenium, reminiscent of the birch forests of Poland and the Ukraine thus providing a sylvan sense of place.
Directed by Eugene Dizon, there are a number of memorable tunes including “Tradition,” “If I Were a Rich Man,” and of course “Sunrise Sunset”.
The full pit orchestra of twenty musicians (all members of Union Local 10-208) with conductor Valerie Gebert elevates the production with a sound quality that simply cannot be adequately duplicated by a smaller ensemble.
Specific rituals and events depicted certainly hold true to similar Jewish events. For this reason, Fiddler holds a certain sentimentality for many. But it becomes a universal story because each of us have experienced or witnessed power with an unfair imbalance.
Empathy is crucial to the enjoyment of this story because it is presented from the perspective of the victims who in this case are Tevye and his community.
Those who have felt the sting of expulsion or have been labeled as “other” should be able to identify.
That is why it is limiting to see this only as a Jewish story. It is a story that compels us to consider the plight and position of those with less power or those who are struggling to maintain their sense of personal identity within a dominant group.
Details: Fiddler on the Roof presented by Music Theater Works at North Shore Center for the Performing Arts, 9501 Skokie Blvd, Skokie, through August 17, 2025. Running time, including intermission, is 2 hours and 45 minutes. Visit MusicTheaterWorks.com for tickets and information.
Review by Reno Lovison
For more shows and reviews visit Theatre in Chicago